The Ships, Shores, Stories, and Sounds of the Great Lakes
Newsletter
Sounds of the Lakes

The lakes have their own songs.

Sailor ballads, a 1976 hit, and the folklorist who saved them.

Long before radio, sailors on the lakes sang to keep time hauling lines and to remember the ships they lost. Most of those songs nearly vanished with the schooners. Here are the ones worth knowing, where to hear them, and where they came from.

SongGordon Lightfoot · 1976

The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald

Gordon Lightfoot wrote the ballad within a year of the wreck, and it appeared on his 1976 album Summertime Dream. It reached No. 1 in Canada and No. 2 on the Billboard Hot 100, held out of the top spot by Rod Stewart. Lightfoot considered it his finest work.

He grew up in Orillia, Ontario, near Lake Huron’s Georgian Bay. The song names Detroit’s Mariners’ Church, whose rector tolled the bell 29 times the morning after the wreck, once for each man lost.

Step through the Fitzgerald’s final voyage →

Sailor songEscanaba to Cleveland · days of sail

Red Iron Ore

One of the oldest and best loved Great Lakes ballads. It follows the crew of the E.C. Roberts hauling iron ore from Escanaba, Michigan, to the Cleveland mills, and the dusty, back-breaking work of loading it by hand.

In 1938 the Library of Congress recorded former sailor Asel Trueblood singing it for Alan Lomax. Trueblood said sailors sang it as a drinking song.

Sailor songBuffalo to Milwaukee

The Bigler

A comic song about a slow, flat-bottomed timber scow, the J. Bigler, beating her way from Buffalo to Milwaukee. She was no beauty and no record-setter, which is the joke.

The real Bigler went down with a load of stone in September 1884 near Marquette. The Library of Congress holds a 1938 recording of a sailor who said he once walked her deck.

SongHenry Clay Work · 1861 · Milwaukee

Lost on the Lady Elgin

In September 1860 the excursion steamer Lady Elgin sank off Winnetka, Illinois, after a collision with the schooner Augusta, on the way home to Milwaukee. About 300 people died, many of them members of the Irish Union Guard of Milwaukee’s Third Ward.

Henry Clay Work wrote this memorial song in 1861, and people kept singing it for generations. Great Lakes singer Lee Murdock has recorded it. A monument to the victims stands in Milwaukee’s Calvary Cemetery.

HistoryIvan H. Walton · 1930s

The man who saved the songs

Shanties faded from the lakes once steam replaced sail. In the 1930s University of Michigan folklorist Ivan Walton went port to port, including Beaver Island, recording songs, weather signs and stories from the last schooner men before they were gone.

His work became Windjammers: Songs of the Great Lakes Sailors (2002), edited by Joe Grimm, and his journals were published as Songquest, which is free to read online.

Listening shelfSongs from the sea, sung on the lakes

Salt water cousins

Lake sailors sang plenty of ocean songs too, like “The Flying Cloud” and “The Cumberland’s Crew.” This shelf is for sea songs we love that aren’t from the lakes.

McGinty’s “The Nellie J. Banks” tells of a Prince Edward Island rum-running schooner during Prohibition. For more in that Celtic, open-water spirit, try The Waterboys.

Coming to this page

Shows on the water this week, festivals, and places along the shore to hear live music. If you play near the lake or book a stage by the water, tell us through the weekly almanac.