The stories sailors tell. Always marked as lore, never passed off as fact.
Ghost ships, haunted lights, lake monsters and the wrecks behind the legends: 18 stories from all five lakes, plus a shelf of 34 books to go deeper. History is labeled history. Lore is labeled lore. Every fact is sourced.
History and loreOff Two Rivers, Wisconsin · Lake Michigan
The Christmas Tree Ship
In November 1912 the three-masted schooner Rouse Simmons left Michigan’s Upper Peninsula loaded with Christmas trees for Chicago, where Captain Herman Schuenemann sold them straight from the deck. She foundered near Two Rivers with everyone aboard.
For years afterward, trees from the lost ship washed up on the beach. In 1971 a Milwaukee diver, Kent Bellrichard, found the wreck about six miles off Rawley Point, her hold still holding the remains of trees.
The lore: for decades sailors told of a ghost schooner on the lake, her deck piled high with evergreens, and some people still say they see her on moonlit nights in November. Another story says the ship’s rats left her before she sailed.
History and loreOff Isle Royale and Passage Island · Lake Superior
The Bannockburn, Flying Dutchman of Lake Superior
On November 20, 1902, the Canadian steel freighter Bannockburn left Fort William, Ontario (now Thunder Bay) with a load of grain, bound down the lakes for Georgian Bay. The next evening the passenger steamer Huronic passed her in worsening weather. Nobody saw her again.
About twenty men were aboard. No wreck has ever been found, and her registry was closed at the end of that year. A lone life jacket is about all the lake gave back.
The lore: within a year sailors were reporting her on stormy nights, running through the mist and never making port. By 1909 the writer James Oliver Curwood was calling her the Flying Dutchman of the inland seas, and to some sailors a sighting is still a warning of bad weather ahead.
In 1679 the French explorer René-Robert Cavelier de La Salle had a small barque built above Niagara Falls. Le Griffon was the first full-sized sailing ship on the upper Great Lakes. She crossed Erie and Huron to Michilimackinac and on to the Green Bay area, where she took on a load of furs and was sent back east.
She never arrived. By the end of November 1679 she was given up as lost, and La Salle never learned what happened to her: storm, mutiny or attack were all suggested at the time.
The lore: wreck hunters call her the holy grail of the Great Lakes. Discoveries are announced every few years, from Lake Huron islands to northern Lake Michigan. None has been confirmed.
HistoryOff Presqu’ile Point, Ontario · Lake Ontario
HMS Speedy and the court that never arrived
In October 1804 the small Provincial Marine schooner Speedy left York (now Toronto) for the new district town of Newcastle on Presqu’ile Point. Aboard were a judge, the solicitor general, lawyers, witnesses and an Indigenous prisoner, Ogetonicut, going to stand trial for the killing of a settler.
A snowstorm caught her near Presqu’ile. People on shore lit bonfires to guide her in; she was lost from sight and went down with everyone aboard. Upper Canada lost a share of its leadership in one night, and the planned town of Newcastle never recovered.
A treasure hunter claimed to have found her in 1990 but never proved it. The wreck is still unconfirmed.
HistoryChicago River at Clark Street · Lake Michigan
The Eastland: Chicago’s deadliest day
On the morning of July 24, 1915, thousands of Western Electric workers and their families boarded the excursion steamer Eastland on the Chicago River for a company picnic across the lake. Still tied to her dock between Clark and LaSalle streets, she rolled onto her side.
844 people died in about twenty feet of water, steps from shore. Twenty-two entire families were lost. It remains the greatest loss of life from a single shipwreck on the Great Lakes, and more people died than in the Great Chicago Fire.
The ship herself was raised and went on to serve the Navy as the gunboat USS Wilmette.
HistorySuperior, Michigan, Huron and Erie · November 7 to 10, 1913
The White Hurricane of 1913
Sailors call it the Big Blow, the Freshwater Fury, the White Hurricane. Two storm systems merged over the lakes and stalled, bringing a blizzard with hurricane-force wind. Over four days more than 250 sailors died and at least a dozen ships sank, with dozens more driven ashore.
Lake Huron took the worst of it. On the evening of November 9, in about six hours, eight ships and 187 lives were lost there. A National Weather Service reconstruction found gusts over 80 mph and waves to about 36 feet. Some of those ships have never been found.
Every November 10, the Mariners’ Remembrance in Detroit marks both this storm and the Edmund Fitzgerald.
HistoryNear Gull Island, northern Lake Michigan · 1958
The Carl D. Bradley and the town that waited
On November 18, 1958, the limestone carrier Carl D. Bradley, 639 feet long and then one of the biggest ships on the lakes, was running empty for home at Rogers City, Michigan, when a gale broke her in two in northern Lake Michigan.
Of 35 men aboard, two survived a night on a raft: first mate Elmer Fleming and deck watchman Frank Mays. Twenty-three of the dead came from Rogers City, a town of a few thousand people. Mays, the last survivor, spent decades telling the story and died in 2021.
In the early hours of November 29, 1966, the 60-year-old ore carrier Daniel J. Morrell was running up Lake Huron on her last trip of the season when a storm tore her apart. It took about eight minutes from the alarm to the water.
Watchman Dennis Hale and three shipmates reached a raft. Hale, who had run on deck in little more than his shorts, was the only one alive when a Coast Guard helicopter found him 38 hours later. Twenty-eight men died. He barely spoke of it for almost thirty years, then wrote a book and told the story to anyone who asked.
HistoryOff Port Washington, Wisconsin · Lake Michigan · 1998
The Linda E. never came home
Before dawn on December 11, 1998, the fish tug Linda E. cleared the Port Washington piers with three men aboard: owner Leif Weborg, Scott Matta and Warren Olson. She was built in 1937 at Burger Boat in Manitowoc. By mid-morning they had about 1,000 pounds of chubs aboard. Then nothing.
The weather was mild. There was no distress call, no oil slick, no debris. The Coast Guard searched roughly 3,000 square miles and found nothing. It became Wisconsin’s great modern lake mystery.
In June 2000 a Navy minesweeper, USS Defender, found her upright in 260 feet of water about seven miles out. The Coast Guard concluded she had most likely been run down by a passing tug and barge and sank in seconds. Memorials to the crew stand in Sturgeon Bay and on Wentworth Avenue in Milwaukee’s Bay View.
The line is older than the song, and Gordon Lightfoot made it famous. Most drowning victims eventually float, because bacteria inside the body produce gas. Lake Superior’s deep water sits near 39°F (4°C) all year, cold enough to all but stop that process.
So the bodies stay down. Divers on deep Superior wrecks have found remains preserved for decades. Folklore and physics agree on this one.
The Seul Choix Point Lighthouse on the Upper Peninsula was commissioned in 1886 and finished in 1895. It is often called one of the most haunted lights on the Great Lakes.
The lore: visitors and caretakers tell of a former keeper, Captain Joseph Willie Townshend, who died at the station in 1910 and never quite left, along with reports of two women and a little girl. The light is open for seasonal tours, and the stories are part of the visit.
LoreWhite River Light Station, Whitehall, Michigan · Lake Michigan
Captain Robinson’s footsteps
William Robinson pushed for a light at the mouth of the White River, helped lay its stone, and kept it for about 47 years while he and his wife Sarah raised a large family there. In 1919, at 87, he was told to retire and hand the light to his grandson. He died at the station before he had to move out.
The lore: museum staff report footsteps on the spiral stair at night, with the tap of a cane, and dust rags left out that are found folded away, credited to Sarah. The light station is now a museum, open in season.
The Old Presque Isle Lighthouse was disconnected from electricity in 1979 during a restoration.
The lore: people keep reporting a glow in the lantern anyway. The story centers on George Parris, who cared for the light with his wife Lorraine from the 1960s into the 1990s, and who, the story goes, is still tending it. Some caretakers tell the story openly; others dispute it.
Anishinaabe traditionAgawa Rock and Michipicoten Island · Lake Superior
Mishipeshu, the Great Lynx
In Ojibwe and wider Anishinaabe tradition, Mishipeshu, the Great Lynx or underwater panther, is a powerful being of the deep water, said to make its home at Michipicoten Island and to hold and protect Lake Superior’s copper.
Its image is painted in red ochre at Agawa Rock in Lake Superior Provincial Park, a sacred site called Mazinaubikiniguning, “the adorned rock.” Researcher Selwyn Dewdney documented the site in 1958. Visitors are asked to treat it with respect.
This is living Indigenous tradition, not a ghost story, and the almanac presents it that way.
Pressie, the serpent of the Porcupine Mountains shore
The lore: Lake Superior’s monster takes her name from the Presque Isle River in the western Upper Peninsula, where some of the best-known sightings happened. Descriptions run to a long dark serpent with a horse-like head, sometimes put at 75 feet. Stories of steamer crews spotting her go back to the 1890s.
Skeptics point to lake sturgeon, which can top six feet and look prehistoric. Either way, Pressie is now firmly part of the U.P.’s character.
LoreSandusky Bay and the Lake Erie Islands, Ohio · Lake Erie
South Bay Bessie, the Lake Erie Monster
The lore: reports of a great snake in Lake Erie go back to 1793. In 1912 residents of Kelleys Island said they found something huge thrashing in the ice. Sightings bunched up again in the 1980s and 1990s, when a Port Clinton newspaper held a naming contest and “South Bay Bessie” won. A Huron marina owner even offered a Lloyd’s-backed reward for her capture.
The likeliest explanation is an outsized sturgeon. Cleveland kept the legend anyway: it has given its name to a beer and a hockey team.
In May 1891 the schooner Thomas Hume sailed out alongside a sister ship. The other vessel turned back ahead of a storm; the Hume was never seen again. Twenty-one years later the Rouse Simmons vanished too.
The lore: those losses feed the legend of a “Lake Michigan Triangle” where ships disappear. Lake storms explain most of it; the legend lives on anyway.
Great Lakes sailors believed that every gull carried the soul of a drowned sailor. Folklorist Ivan Walton recorded beliefs like this, along with weather signs and songs, from the last schooner men in the 1930s.
Henry Wadsworth Longfellow · 1855 · Ticknor and Fields
“By the shores of Gitche Gumee.” A famous poem, but it borrows and mixes Ojibwe stories through a settler lens. Read it beside Indigenous sources like Johnston.